Saturday, May 5, 2012

One group: Worship

An amazing discussion, full of rage and appreciation and frustration and hope. I was at the Worship table.

Opinions much? O yes.

Do we...throw it all away and build worship anew from the very ground (or beneath the ground) up? "YESYESYES IT IS THE ONLY WAY!" says a longtime member.

Do we...preserve the form, recognizing our UCC-ness that goes way back, but tweak this bit or that? "WHY OF COURSE THAT IS JUST THE TICKET!" says another.

Do we...send some people off to think about the long term, but also right here, right now, TOMORROW in fact, start experimenting with forms, right in real time, in our service, that touch and serve those who are currently feeling undertouched and not much served? "WELL THIS IS OBVIOUSLY THE WAY TO GO!" says one more.

Our table leader strives to distill it all with kindness and accuracy. There is so much passion. People care *so.* *hard.*

Which brings me to a greater awareness of one of the strengths we listed of Plymouth worship: Loyalty. Man, we are loyal. There is so much loyalty, the room can barely contain it. We love our church. We are so filled with desire for it. Tears come to our eyes, we care so much. We are crybabies for Plymouth, a little bit.

And just now I am being compassionately cared for in the most amazing way. A fellow pilgrim creeps up behind with the most perfect gift I could receive in this moment. As I type she is using thumbs of magic to work out the knots. My shoulders and neck are reborn under her fingers. How did she know?

6 comments:

  1. Becky Colwell here. Hello All. Thanks for being there and doing the work.

    Some shots at the elephant:
    - I think that for me and many at Plymouth our worship forms and theology are way out of sync with how we actually see God and how we try to live our faith.
    - Plymouth people of all ages are a pretty kick-ass group. (We have some of the feistiest old people of any place in town.) Somehow we have backed away from this in worship. We are letting our service have more and more forms that were valid for people from other times, places, and traditions. Where are our forms?
    - "People will forget what you do and say. They will never forget how you made them feel." Worship at Plymouth does not leave me "feeling" anything good. It makes me feel bored, wrong and stupid.
    - How do we actually see God? Is God artificially somber? How do we want to embody how we feel about God? And how we believe God feels about us.
    - Clapping is how EVERYONE in our culture expresses joy, agreement, enthusiasm and participation. It's only wrong in worship because we made it wrong. Making it wrong makes me and visitors and young people feel weirdly inappropriate, uninformed, and out of the club.
    - Chanting "Christ have mercy" may be ecclesiastically correct on some continent, but to me it's as if we hadn't heard or believed anything Jesus ever said.
    - We are locked into a lectionary that forces the reading of really primitive passages. It's assumed that "we all know" that it has to be read in historical context, but why? Why not read things that are have meaning, that are powerful and faith shaping now, in this place, in this time, really, to these people.
    - Who are we trying to please? I don't want to please old-world Anglicans, New England Puritans, or mid-western Lutherans.

    I would like to fill the pews with creative, free-thinking left-coast punks who are spiritual, not religious, who are passionate about their faith and ethics, even if that is not particularly defined. If they are capable - still of an age - of reproducing, that would be great. And if they are some of the dozens of awesome young people who went through our Sunday school and youth programs and then vanished when worship was the only thing left for them to do at Plymouth, I would scream for joy!

    These are the kind of things you can say when you're not in the room. :)

    Love you all.
     - Becky Colwell

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Becky,

    Yo, thanks. I want it and crave it. It's been a fascinating day "in the room." I tried to be as honest and kind and all the right things in every small group, while also speaking truth as I saw it.

    But then in the large group I was a big chicken. I didn't want to say it again, because I didn't want to be that person, the whiner, the "but, but, but..." person. I was in groups that were SO vibrant and SO passionate, but then I looked at the papers and it wasn't there. I kind of felt like I flunked Retreat, but I really, truly tried.

    Plus, I didn't wholly flunk. I got to be with people I adore and admire and exchange ideas with them. I got to see the Confirmation class be awesome. I love that program.

    I think a lot of people felt great about what we got done today - joy! I'm grateful for that. Others who spoke to me used the word "railroaded" do describe how they felt by the end. I *know* people here all want what's best for this church. Folks did a lot of work to ensure the space was safe. I have a ton of gratitude for that.

    I'm going to sort out my overall feelings. The thing I feel best about is the number of times I heard people say "I so want worship to touch my heart." Even if it didn't get on the giant papers, or I didn't recognize it there - I heard it and heard it and heard it!

    xo
    Margot



    I love you all, too.
    Margot

    ReplyDelete
  3. janedunkel@gmail.comMay 5, 2012 at 7:06 PM

    Thanks for hanging in there, Margot. I have many thoughts but sense it has been a long day for all of you, so here's hoping the evening involves some rest, relaxation, dance, music and joy!

    To continuing the dialogue, and not giving up,

    Jane

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Margo!
    Tom's struggling, and we can't be there.
    Please, please, if you can, I want you to "...be that person. "
    Please think of all the people who will feel betrayed, and that they don't have a place here, if the railroad runs over their heart.
    I hope Confirmation is having a good time.
    - Becky

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm hoping what is perceived as a railroad is a difference in understanding of the goal of the current process. If one outcome is "create a framework that makes it possible to start new initiatives", that accommodates, for instance, alternate visions of worship. The practicality of the process isn't adequate to capture all the poetic and heart-full nuances of the possibilities that can grow from this seed. I believe the cry is heard and will have a response.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think you're right, Ruth, that the cry is indeed heard. Thanks for that! And Becky, oh how I don't want to betray the trust that *everyone* who loves Plymouth but can't be here this weekend put in all us who can.
    I felt a little hopeless a couple of hours ago, but a dinnertime convo renewed my confidence that some of the folks who are charged with distilling from here definitely have a sense of the longing. And not just as a vague yearning, but in some of the specifics.

    So many folks are standing by offering to bring concrete ideas for new life and heart and worship that pulls us together. I myself have a list :)

    Here's something that tickles me pinkly: Many of us have blahblah'd a great deal today about diverse ways of worship and being together. Because I am thick as a rock, it took me until this moment to realize: Lookit! We're doing it, right here, right now! Whee!

    So I hope all you participators-from-afar are wearing your Pioneer hats. Or chaps. Wait, what do pioneers wear? Bonnets? Yeah, that.

    Prayers and thoughts with Tom. Anthony and I had to come back to Seattle early for our own germy reasons. Is there anything we can be helpful?
    xo
    Margot

    ReplyDelete